Export Certificate With Private Key Greyed Out

In SSL->Certificates->Install, I browse my PC to select the. If you see the option to Export the Private Key is greyed out, then your Administrator account Password does not match the value when the Server was installed. Then click "Next". Exports a private certificate issued by a private certificate authority (CA) for use anywhere. I have downloaded a digital certificate with private key from authority CA using a link. Unable to Export Certificate with Private Key as the. In the console tree under the logical store that contains the certificate to export, click Certificates. When exporting the server certificate from the server's personal certificate store, you may not have the option to export the private key. I then import the certificate into the Personal store using the Certificates snap-in. PFX is short for Personal inFormation eXchange. cer -out certificate. An attempt to manually export the certificate with its private key from the certificate store indicated that there was no private key to be exported, as that option was greyed out. This is a security measure to prevent a possible compromise of the server's. Follow the Certificate Export Wizard to back up your certificate to a. The certificate won’t work without the private key. This procedure exports a server (local) certificate and private key together as a password protected PKCS12 file. uk to a new machine. On the Export Private Key screen select the Yes, export the private key radio button and click the Next > button. When you reset the print server back to its default factory settings, the certificate and the private key that are installed will be deleted. I want to export the complete certificate (public and private key) so that I can import it in my Visual Administrator. The second page of the export wizard should ask if you want to export the private key. If you try and export that certificate in PFX format its greyed out, because the private key is missing. When I try to export from with the CA, I don't get an option " yes, export the private key" and on the export file format " Personal Information Exchange - PKCS#12(. All the certificate and key files are in nsconfig/ssl directory. Note: If this option is grayed out then there is no private key associated with the certificate or you do not have the admin privileges to export such a file. Click Yes, export the private key. Steps to create Point-to-Site VPN using Azure Portal. Before you begin Role required: admin About this task If your Certificate Authority is not a trusted third. Exports a private certificate issued by a private certificate authority (CA) for use anywhere. 2) Sign in to developer. (MimiKatz 2. With iSECPartners’ jailbreak you can export it anyway. Once the encoding is correct, just ensure the extension is CRT or CER. " However, when I then try to export the certificate, the "Yes, export the private key" option is greyed out, and there is a note on the dialog box which says "Note: The associated private key cannot be. As the name suggests, this is a tool geared at aiding in the recovery of your AD FS configuration / environment, in the event of server failure or disaster. Normally a simple task of installing a certificate for IIS and Exchange 2010, however on this occasion once I’d imported the crt file into the Certificate mmc, I couldn’t then export it as a pfx certificate which Exchange 2010 requires for it to be imported. However, I don't seem to have the option to export as a PFX file. For example, if we need to transfer SSL certificate from one windows server to other, You can simply export it as. Jailbreak exports certificates marked as non-exportable from the Windows certificate store. msc in search) and go to Computer Configuration > Windows Settings > Security Settings > Public. Click the Browse. I know that it is easy to circumvent this, but it's meant to be an additional barrier. Why is the option to export my Certificate private key greyed out? Unable to Set Default Selection for SMS/Text on the Reg Config Tab Role Information is Improperly Passed to SharePoint. Seahorse is a GUI tool for creating and managing OpenPGP keys, securely storing passwords, and creating and managing SSH certificates. PFX)" is greyed out". Display configuration elements in which the certificate is used (click on Check certificate use), Confirm the deletion of the private key (click on Confirm deletion). This opens the Certificate Export wizard and walks us through the process of exporting the certificate to the location of our choosing. An export of the registry key will contain the complete certificate including the private key. Before you begin Role required: admin About this task If your Certificate Authority is not a trusted third. "Yes, export the private key" option is greyed out, after the Key/CSR pair has been generated. Select Yes, export the private key. Click Next to the Export Wizard welcome dialog box. It uses GPG as the back-end OpenPGP implementation. This article provides steps to export a root CA certificate with private key from a Microsoft Authority Server. According to uor description "When i go to the CA to export the new cert", if we want to export the certificate on CA, we can not export it with private key. Slipping out of the Microsoft stable recently with little fanfare, the AD FS Rapid Restore Tool. Trust manually installed certificate profiles in iOS In iOS 10. The Certificate Authority (CA) provides you with your SSL Certificate (public key file). Once you install a Code Signing certificate in your browser, you might want to export it from Internet Explorer® or Firefox® to use elsewhere. However, Windows 10 also offers a feature to disable the export of the private key (see below). Updating SQL Data Store Schema to 7. Export the user cert and private key again, this time selecting the "Include all certificates in the certification path if possible" checkbox. Creating, Exporting, and Importing Business Network Cards. I received my COMODO certificate and I can see it in my certificate store but I am not able to select it in Outlook 2013, it just says that I have "no certificates meet the application criteria". You use your server to generate the associated private key file where the CSR was created. ' Cannot backup key because the option to, "Yes, export the private key" is. The reason the option to export the private key is greyed out is because the certificate was created without the option to export keys. For Select cryptographic service provider, make sure RSA, Microsoft Software Key Storage Provider is the only boxed checked. Error: 'ID1001: The certificate does not have an associated private key. During the request the option to Mark keys as exportable is grayed out. Go ahead and click 'Finish' Part 3 - Obtaining your public key Now we need to get your public key, without it vendors wont be able to send you secure messages. We use use here the certificate from https://www. When you want to activate an SSL certificate on your server, you must prove the identity of your website and of your company. Right click on the file and choose > All Tasks > Export. In this scenario, you cannot export the certificate in the required format. pfx) isn’t a valid PKCS#12 key store. The Certificate Authority (CA) provides you with your SSL Certificate (public key file). PFX file is greyed out, and hence restrict me to proceed to the OOB configuration step. The option "Yes, export with private key" was grayed out. Export Certificates Through NetScaler CLI. use openSSL. I’ve private key, which stored in folder AppData\Roaming\Microsoft\Crypto\RSA\. If its not (like you named it ca-cert. Double-click on the certificate name on the 'VPN' tab of Edge object. pfx -inkey…. The certificate request contains information about your server and the company hosting it. PFX) Select Include all certificates in the certification. It is more secure than self-signed as the private key is kept secret. Now that we have got the client certificate for distribution points, let's assign them to the DP's. Once we have that installed in IIS, we should now export the private and public keypair. PFX)" is greyed out". This will run the Certificate Export Wizard. If this is the case, when the certificate was imported, the option to allow the private key to be exported may have been unchecked. Enter a password for the export and click Next. SSL encryption software for export is limited by a U. I know that it is easy to circumvent this, but it's meant to be an additional barrier. exe, but when a certificate is created that way, it's private key cannot be exported. Combine a private key and a certificate into one key store in the PKCS #12 format openssl pkcs12 -export -out keyStore. Error: 'ID1001: The certificate does not have an associated private key. I tried this before - and that is a great link for installing certificates, but it fails for ReadyNAS devices at this point because, the certification path root has no certificate to "View" so the "View Certificate" buton is grayed out, which, in the tutorial, is the place where you find and install that certificate for that site/device. If you see the option to Export the Private Key is greyed out, then your Administrator account Password does not match the value when the Server was installed. Double-click on the certificate name on the 'VPN' tab of Edge object. The private key export box is grayed out. But that's typically not needed. I don't think iPhone Configuration Utility will let you choose an invalid Identity Certificate, so that could be why the menu is greyed-out. When i go to the CA to export the new. Remote Desktop Services 2016, Standard Deployment – Part 4 – RD Web Access (Part1) Next we need to export the certificate with private key and configure. If you have successfully installed your certificate, however you wish to make a backup with the private key, if you do not have full admin rights, Windows will not allow it. Click on Next. pfx file, but we can’t directly do it. Click the checkbox to Export public key and / or Export private key, as required. Select the private key associated with your. 3) Download the certificate (. 509 certificate is a digital document that has been encoded and/or digitally signed according to RFC 5280. As the name “private” key says, you should never export this one outside of the server that uses the certificate and keep it private. Launch Seahorse. If this is the case, when the certificate was imported, the option to allow the private key to be exported may have been unchecked. Symantec helps consumers and organizations secure and manage their information-driven world. The cert will appear in the certificate manager with the private key included. So I'm a bit stuck. Once that was opened you need to select the ‘Content’ tab and select ‘Certificates’ Select ‘Export’ and ‘Next’. • If the "Yes, export the private key" option is available, make sure it is checked. Click Finish to perform an immediate online request, which once successful will also automatically import the certificate into the local server and pair it with the private key. What’s after the purchase? Getting started and activating your SSL CSR generation instructions CSR and certificate installation related questions Multi-domain. Your choice is stored in the key storage property identifier that is key-storage specific. -----END CERTIFICATE----- 2. 3rd party HTTPS certificates for the admin interface? Has anyone been able to install 3rd-party HTTPs certificates on FAZ 5. Symantec helps consumers and organizations secure and manage their information-driven world. 0 Created Certificate: No Exporting of Private. 5+ Why is the option to export my Certificate private key greyed out? As such, if you create a new realm on the master server, you will need to do the same on the slave(s). I would like to quote Brian Komar on this case: A common misconception is that the same certificate and private key pair must be deployed at each Web server in the cluster. This blog is for those who choose to deploy the Column Master Key in the local store of Windows rather than using Azure Key Vault. Wondering if you could help. Expand Key options and select 2048 in the Key size drop down. Open your Internet Explorer browser and click on Tools and then on Options. On the server in question I can see the machine certificate in MMC but not under IIS. When exporting an identity certificate on printers with firmware earlier than v23. the correct command for certificate request is :. 2) Sign in to developer. This tells me that the certificate you have now does *not* have a private key attached. There may be times when a machine that is not a domain member needs to obtain a machine certificate from a Microsoft stand-alone CA. I then import the certificate into the Personal store using the Certificates snap-in. How to fix that : 1. We have documentation on exporting this key in our APNS Setup Guide, in the Export the. For example, if you want to copy the certificate to another computer to use it there or as a backup, you should export a certificate with a private key by first grabbing it by adding a where-object clause to identify it. Follow the Certificate Export Wizard, being sure to Export the Private Key. But, it looks like that for some reasons, the Private Key is missing, the option to export the private key along with the certificate is greyed out : I do have a file named after the Certificate Thumbprint on \AppData\Roaming\Microsoft\SystemCertificates\My\Certificates\. All the certificate and key files are in nsconfig/ssl directory. The Export-Certificate cmdlet exports a certificate from a certificate store to a file. 2 User Authentication. Because all servers will serve the same host name, administrators generate single certificate with exportable private key and import the same certificate on all cluster nodes. To do that download/export at first the certificate and place at on your local hard disk. Auto-enrollment is a useful feature of Active Directory Certificate Services (AD CS). Right click on it, All Tasks -> Export. If you are trying to export windows certificate with private key, and windows export wizard provides no such possibility (export with private key is grayed out) because private key has been install as non-exportable (what is the default when importing, what almost nobody changes), there is a great tool mimikatz that makes this possible. Note: If yes is greyed out, this could mean that for some reason, your private key. But the new certificate doesn't appear on the list. Backing Up The SSL Certificate Apache stores both the SSL certificate and its private key as two separate files. How can I get public and private keys out of IIS? Notes. The requested certificate is directly stored in the user store (by default) or the local computer store, if specified during the request. If the radio button ‘ Yes, export the private key ’ is grayed out, it means that either the private key was not marked as exportable during the certificate request generation, or that. To do this, Microsoft says you need to Export the Cert/Private Key from the MMC. p7b -certfile CACert. To Export a Code Signing Certificate from Internet Explorer. To replace. If the private key doesn't exist on your computer then you can't export the certificate as pfx. If “Yes, export the private key” is greyed out (that is, you can’t select it), stop here and contact our help desk at [email protected] Adding the Private Key to the Certificate Once the certificate is obtained, the private key needs to be added to it in order for Qlik Sense to use it for server authentication and certification. When trying to perform an export function using Windows Certificate Snap In from the MMC the option to include the private key is 'greyed' out. In other words, there is no information in the certificate about the exportability of the related private key. 5+ Why is the option to export my Certificate private key greyed out? As such, if you create a new realm on the master server, you will need to do the same on the slave(s). To do so, select one of the Export options from the Conversions menu. The option next to, "Yes, export the private key" is greyed out. com as Account Holder and create new iOS Distribution Key with the signing request. If you need to move a root trusted or self-signed SSL certificate from one Windows Machine to another this article will detail the process. When exporting the server certificate from the server's personal certificate store, you may not have the option to export the private key. Updating SQL Data Store Schema to 7. You can either click Details to mark the key as exportable or use IIS to create the certificate. Right-click the client/agent certificate and select all tasks> export; Select Next and you will see two options, Yes, export the private key or No, do not export the private key. Are you exporting your certificate from the Personal Certificate Store ? Also double-click the certificateat the bottom it should say "You have a private key that corresponds to this certificate. Click 'Next' 11. April 2018 update) when importing a PFX, an option like [ ] Protect private key using virtualization-based security (non-exportable) appears on the import wizard. The option to include all certificates in the certification path should be selected. Give the private key a password of your choice 12. Click Next to the Export Wizard welcome dialog box. Hi, The document says that in order to correct this problem, you will need access to the original certificate backup (. However, Windows 10 also offers a feature to disable the export of the private key (see below). Exporting unexportable certificates less than 1 minute read You sometimes run into cases where a certificate was imported by another sysadmin and he forgot to check the option to export the private key. On the Actions menu, choose Export (private certificates only). ' Cannot backup key because the option to, "Yes, export the private key" is. Export a PEM-Format Private Key in Windows. Take the file you exported (e. If I try to Export the certificate from MMC, it doesn't allow to export with the private key. When trying to perform an export function using Windows Certificate Snap In from the MMC the option to include the private key is 'greyed' out. > Perhaps I am confused as I should instead export the key (as opposed to Certificate)? When exporting the "Key" > (when I am in the "Private Keys" tab--NOT the "Certificates" tab), there I do see the option to to > "Export the Private Part of the Key too" that I could uncheck. WARNING: If you purchase with a non Microsoft Browser, the certificate will be installed to that browser and you will need to export the certificate from the browser. In the Certificate Export wizard, select Yes, export the private key, select pfx file, and then check Include all certificates in the certification path if possible, and. When i go to the CA to export the new. For this reason we are striving difficult to find details about Ca Certificate Template To Issue Greyed Out anyplace we could. p12 certificate so you can use it on OneSignal, Urban Airship, Firebase FCM or etc, but when you open the. This posting is ~5 years years old. Problem is, the option to export the Private Key is greyed out. Support CryptoAPI and CNG (CNG patch requires admin rights, not f. Do not select Include all certificates in the certification path if possible option. With this we get a self signed local certificate and a local private key certificate with the name of “RecoveryAgent”. Make sure that the option 'Yes, export the private key' can be ticked or it is not grayed out. 2 Comments on Oracle wallet creation by using existing certificate & private key And Import into OMS. To do this, Microsoft says you need to Export the Cert/Private Key from the MMC. I have purchased the SSL certificate from GoDaddy and i need to install this SSL certificate on siteground server because my site is hosted on siteground. The export wizard displays. Can not export private key because the option is greyed out. Send the certificate request, along with documents proving your identity, to a CA. Create an Edge object with VPN properties. I've been following blogs on how to create What If parameters. You have successfully retrieved a. This is a. Now my local WSUS can reply on the port 8531 correctly. key in the Name field. Do not select Export all extended properties in the options. PFX file from the AMT Provisioning Certificate. Select GnuPG keys. If you want to keep the same certificate and the private key after resetting the scan server, export them before resetting and re-install them. This posting is ~5 years years old. $\begingroup$ For the normal encryption use case, where you want to obfuscate the message content so that only the recipient can read it, you would be correct: the sender would use the public key, and the receiver would use the private key. (MimiKatz 2. If you're creating macros in Microsoft Office, or other code that needs to be signed and trusted for internal use, you can easily create code signing certificates using an Enterprise Certificate Authority (ECA). pfx -inkey…. If you are exporting the certificate to place it on a different service that you own, select Yes, export the private key. crt -inkey san_domain_com. Once you receive your certificate file it MUST be imported onto the computer where the CSR file was created as the private key exists on this machine and is never transmitted within the CSR. (This option is greyed out when the key is not exportable. Jailbreak is a tool for exporting certificates marked as non-exportable from the Windows certificate store. (Be sure that the private key is exportable. ' Cannot backup key because the option to, "Yes, export the private key" is. Once you obtain someone's certificate and add it to your trusted identities list, you can encrypt documents for them. If you have successfully installed your certificate, however you wish to make a backup with the private key, if you do not have full admin rights, Windows will not allow it. You exported your own certificate in order to publish it, and you have imported the certificate of your correspondence partner and thus attached it to your "key ring" (i. exe" req -new -key "C:\private. Exporting unexportable certificates less than 1 minute read You sometimes run into cases where a certificate was imported by another sysadmin and he forgot to check the option to export the private key. openssl pkcs12 -export -out certificate. Adding the Private Key to the Certificate Once the certificate is obtained, the private key needs to be added to it in order for Qlik Sense to use it for server authentication and certification. Import and Export from Windows using MMC ; Renew your SSL certificate without removing your current certificate ; SSL Diagnostics Version 1. If you did everything right in the steps above you now have a website that contains both the private key as the public key. Export certificates marked as not exportable in the Windows certificate manager Unknown bolt | 2016-06-21. In this case the option to export the private key is greyed out and not available. Generate a key pair; Examine a certificate file; Examine an SSL/TLS connection; Examine a certification request file; Examine a CRL file; Import a trusted certificate; Import a key pair; Delete a keystore entry; Export a keystore entry; Rename a keystore entry; Examine a keystore entry's certificate; Clone a keystore key pair entry. To do so, select one of the Export options from the Conversions menu. However the default Code Signing Template does not allow us to export the private key. If the ‘Default level’ is greyed out, as below, then the level is already set to default. Powershell script to request and export Certificates with Private Key (PFX) Now we need to export these certificate with private key (in PFX format) and share it. If you see the option to Export the Private Key is greyed out, then your Administrator account Password does not match the value when the Server was installed. I've been following blogs on how to create What If parameters. openssl pkcs12 -export -out certificate. For this reason we are striving difficult to find details about Ca Certificate Template To Issue Greyed Out anyplace we could. , Exchange User) and select All Tasks, Export, from the context menu. My hope was that I could just get a private key for the "actual" certificate and decrypt everything, but when going to export them the private key option is greyed out in the wizard. But for my case, the option to export the. In order to correct this problem, you will need access to the original certificate backup file. PFX "Personal. Now since you deleted the cert you can not export its pivate key to file while exporting the cert. When I try to export from with the CA, I don't get an option " yes, export the private key" and on the export file format " Personal Information Exchange - PKCS#12(. (See How to export the certificate and private key. If "Yes, export the private key" is greyed out (that is, you can't select it), stop here and contact our help desk at [email protected] Click 'Next' 11. Now when I'm going to export the certificate it will NOT allow me to export with private key. To do this […]. This is possible by maintaining the same private key. Export certificates marked as not exportable in the Windows certificate manager Unknown bolt | 2016-06-21. Select the private key that you wish to backup. Select the Private Key tab. These third-party certificates are actually wallets, in the Oracle sense, because they contain more than just the user certificate; they also contain the private key for that certificate. Open the powershell as administrator 2. No problem for the WSUS Administration part, using IIS and a certificat "Server Authentication, Client Authentication" delivered by my CA (enterprise CA). Sometimes we need to extract private key and certificate from. The option to include all certificates in the certification path should be selected. Have more questions? Don’t hesitate to contact our support team. use openSSL. Assuming your export was successful, you can log off and disable the Administrator account again. In the Import Certificate dialog, type the name of the pending certificate. When you access the HP iLO webinterface, you will be redirected to a HTTPS website. To ensure this problem does not happen in the future (should you want to export the private key again) make sure during the import process that you select the box "mark the private key as exportable. Note: This guide contains a high level approach to backing up and exporting a certificate. We have documentation on exporting this key in our APNS Setup Guide, in the Export the. In the Export Private Key page click on the Yes, export the private key radio button as shown and click on NEXT to continue. On Linux the file is typically named id_rsa. der -outform der -nocrypt Then click on the "Import / export CA certificate" button in Burp, and select "Cert and key in DER format". I found that for a certificate to appear in the "My Certificates" section it has to have the private key associated with it. BouncyCastle and is stored in the Certificate Store of the current user, along with the private key. Browse to your certificate (probably a. €In addition, client and server certificates are exported with the private key. Any help appreciated. Export the Corrected Certificate. I managed to get the certificate from the Certificate Snapin, but I the difference is that there is a private key for this certificate, and the option to export with the private ket is also greyed out. I cannot figure out why this option is greyed out. Follow the Certificate Export Wizard to back up your certificate to a. cer file in Keychain Access and select 'Export', there's no. Is that what you mean?. When trying to export the private key (*. When you want to export exchange certificate from CAS ,the "export private key" is greyed out and you are not able to export the private key. Right click on your key, then click 'Export Certificates…' Browse where you want to save, give it a name, then click 'Save'. Or at least read it, as I wanted to create a. This can not be imported in the rds role wizard. So before I give it to him I want to export that certificate in PCKS#12 with it's private key. If you have successfully installed your certificate, however you wish to make a backup with the private key, if you do not have full admin rights, Windows will not allow it. BouncyCastle and is stored in the Certificate Store of the current user, along with the private key. The problem is that the use of SSL certificates is necessary and Neoload only imports certificates in PKCS12 format. PFX "Personal. If you have trouble with this process (e. Symantec helps consumers and organizations secure and manage their information-driven world. If you want to export a certificate with its private key, choose Personal Information Exchange (p12) as the file format. Export Certificate with Private Key We will leave the options as shown we default and click "Next" We arrived to a screen where you must assign a password and validation to protect the file that contains the exported certificate. Enter a password for the export and click Next. And the certificate was installed with no errors. Backup and restore the local certificates. Import and Export from Windows using MMC ; Renew your SSL certificate without removing your current certificate ; SSL Diagnostics Version 1. If you don’t have and existing PKCS#12 key store (PFX file) from which you want to export a private key and certificate for Graylog, you don’t have to run these commands. Backing Up The SSL Certificate Apache stores both the SSL certificate and its private key as two separate files. In the certificate store, the certificate is stored with some extra data, one of which being "there is a private key for that certificate, held by CSP X under name Y", which allows Windows to get the key when needed. Secondly, your cert is fine. CAUTION: It's possible to create a backup file that doesn't include the private key, but it WON'T be a complete backup copy of your certificate. Start Certificate Manager. 4 using the Security > Certificate Management area, only the public key is exported. If you suspect that your Pass Type ID certificate or Developer ID certificate and private key have been compromised, and would like to request revocation of the certificate, send an email to [email protected] This action is not available (grayed-out option) when the selected certificate does not have a private key. For example: For the above same cert, when I export on CA server, I can not export cert with private key. This opens the Certificate Export wizard and walks us through the process of exporting the certificate to the location of our choosing. The Certificate Export Wizard will start. I also am not able to export the private key of the certificate because it's greyed out. I just need to export a computer's certificate (public key only + complete chain) from my server (not a CA server). pfx is also greyed out. If you try and export that certificate in PFX format its greyed out, because the private key is missing. Right click the certificate and choose All Tasks > Export. Export Certificates Through NetScaler CLI. hidden text to trigger early load of fonts ПродукцияПродукцияПродукция Продукция Các sản phẩmCác sản phẩmCác sản. In the console tree under the logical store that contains the certificate to export, click Certificates. Select "Yes, export the private key" and click Next. Because all servers will serve the same host name, administrators generate single certificate with exportable private key and import the same certificate on all cluster nodes. You can export the certificate, the certificate chain, and the encrypted private key associated with the public key embedded in the certificate. I want to export the complete certificate (public and private key) so that I can import it in my Visual Administrator. 6: Select Personal Information Exchange – PKCS #12 (. Continue to follow steps in the wizard, and enter a password for the certificate backup file when prompted. Jailbreak is a tool for exporting certificates marked as non-exportable from the Windows certificate store. Windows 10 offers certmgr. Ca Certificate Template To Issue Greyed Out is among the coolest point talked about by a lot of people on the net. The solution is to simply reimport the certificate from the ORIGINAL. The fact-checkers, whose work is more and more important for those who prefer facts over lies, police the line between fact and falsehood on a day-to-day basis, and do a great job. Today, my small contribution is to pass along a very good overview that reflects on one of Trump’s favorite overarching falsehoods. Namely: Trump describes an America in which everything was going down the tubes under  Obama, which is why we needed Trump to make America great again. And he claims that this project has come to fruition, with America setting records for prosperity under his leadership and guidance. “Obama bad; Trump good” is pretty much his analysis in all areas and measurement of U.S. activity, especially economically. Even if this were true, it would reflect poorly on Trump’s character, but it has the added problem of being false, a big lie made up of many small ones. Personally, I don’t assume that all economic measurements directly reflect the leadership of whoever occupies the Oval Office, nor am I smart enough to figure out what causes what in the economy. But the idea that presidents get the credit or the blame for the economy during their tenure is a political fact of life. Trump, in his adorable, immodest mendacity, not only claims credit for everything good that happens in the economy, but tells people, literally and specifically, that they have to vote for him even if they hate him, because without his guidance, their 401(k) accounts “will go down the tubes.” That would be offensive even if it were true, but it is utterly false. The stock market has been on a 10-year run of steady gains that began in 2009, the year Barack Obama was inaugurated. But why would anyone care about that? It’s only an unarguable, stubborn fact. Still, speaking of facts, there are so many measurements and indicators of how the economy is doing, that those not committed to an honest investigation can find evidence for whatever they want to believe. Trump and his most committed followers want to believe that everything was terrible under Barack Obama and great under Trump. That’s baloney. Anyone who believes that believes something false. And a series of charts and graphs published Monday in the Washington Post and explained by Economics Correspondent Heather Long provides the data that tells the tale. The details are complicated. Click through to the link above and you’ll learn much. But the overview is pretty simply this: The U.S. economy had a major meltdown in the last year of the George W. Bush presidency. Again, I’m not smart enough to know how much of this was Bush’s “fault.” But he had been in office for six years when the trouble started. So, if it’s ever reasonable to hold a president accountable for the performance of the economy, the timeline is bad for Bush. GDP growth went negative. Job growth fell sharply and then went negative. Median household income shrank. The Dow Jones Industrial Average dropped by more than 5,000 points! U.S. manufacturing output plunged, as did average home values, as did average hourly wages, as did measures of consumer confidence and most other indicators of economic health. (Backup for that is contained in the Post piece I linked to above.) Barack Obama inherited that mess of falling numbers, which continued during his first year in office, 2009, as he put in place policies designed to turn it around. By 2010, Obama’s second year, pretty much all of the negative numbers had turned positive. By the time Obama was up for reelection in 2012, all of them were headed in the right direction, which is certainly among the reasons voters gave him a second term by a solid (not landslide) margin. Basically, all of those good numbers continued throughout the second Obama term. The U.S. GDP, probably the single best measure of how the economy is doing, grew by 2.9 percent in 2015, which was Obama’s seventh year in office and was the best GDP growth number since before the crash of the late Bush years. GDP growth slowed to 1.6 percent in 2016, which may have been among the indicators that supported Trump’s campaign-year argument that everything was going to hell and only he could fix it. During the first year of Trump, GDP growth grew to 2.4 percent, which is decent but not great and anyway, a reasonable person would acknowledge that — to the degree that economic performance is to the credit or blame of the president — the performance in the first year of a new president is a mixture of the old and new policies. In Trump’s second year, 2018, the GDP grew 2.9 percent, equaling Obama’s best year, and so far in 2019, the growth rate has fallen to 2.1 percent, a mediocre number and a decline for which Trump presumably accepts no responsibility and blames either Nancy Pelosi, Ilhan Omar or, if he can swing it, Barack Obama. I suppose it’s natural for a president to want to take credit for everything good that happens on his (or someday her) watch, but not the blame for anything bad. Trump is more blatant about this than most. If we judge by his bad but remarkably steady approval ratings (today, according to the average maintained by 538.com, it’s 41.9 approval/ 53.7 disapproval) the pretty-good economy is not winning him new supporters, nor is his constant exaggeration of his accomplishments costing him many old ones). I already offered it above, but the full Washington Post workup of these numbers, and commentary/explanation by economics correspondent Heather Long, are here. On a related matter, if you care about what used to be called fiscal conservatism, which is the belief that federal debt and deficit matter, here’s a New York Times analysis, based on Congressional Budget Office data, suggesting that the annual budget deficit (that’s the amount the government borrows every year reflecting that amount by which federal spending exceeds revenues) which fell steadily during the Obama years, from a peak of $1.4 trillion at the beginning of the Obama administration, to $585 billion in 2016 (Obama’s last year in office), will be back up to $960 billion this fiscal year, and back over $1 trillion in 2020. (Here’s the New York Times piece detailing those numbers.) Trump is currently floating various tax cuts for the rich and the poor that will presumably worsen those projections, if passed. As the Times piece reported: